Logotipo de Revista Mexicana de Fitopatología

Mexican Journal
of Phytopathology

Logotipo Sociedad Mexicana de Fitopatología A.C.

Article filters

Search Papers

Búsquedas previas al 2023, Núm. 3. En la sección Volúmenes 30 - 41 (2012 - 2023).

All the Articles

  • Open access
  • Scientific Article

Phylogenomic diversity and genome mining of type Bacillus species: Searching for genes associated with biological control of phytopathogens

byJosé Jesús Márquez Diego, Andrea Denisse Martinez Vidales, Errikka Patricia Cervantes Enríquez, Abraham Ruiz Castrejón, José Humberto Romero Silva, Maria Edith Ortega Urquieta, Fannie Isela Parra Cota, Sergio de los Santos Villalobos*

Received: 18/July/2023 – Published: 06/March/2024DOI: https://doi.org/10.18781/R.MEX.FIT.2402-9

Abstract Background/Objective. Bacillus is a cosmopolitan bacterial genus with a great genome diversity. Thus, by exploring its genome background, it is possible to understand more about the physiological and biochemical traits involved in its biological control against phytopathogens. The objective of this work was to correlate the phylogenomic relationships of the type species of the genus Bacillus with the presence of gene clusters associated with biological control of plant pathogens, through genome mining.

Materials and Methods. Based on the literature, 336 species belonging to the genus Bacillus have been reported; however, after re-classification, a total of 123 type species have been recognized, and curated genomes were found in the EzBioCloud platform (http://www.ezbiocloud.net/). The overall genome relatedness indices (OGRIs) were used for this work, which indicate how similar two sequences of a genome are. Then, the Realphy platform was used to create the phylogenomic tree 1.13 (Action-based phylogeny constructor reference). Finally, the prediction of biosynthetic gene clusters (BGC) associated with the biological control of phytopathogens was carried out using antiSMASH v6.0 (https://antismash. secondarymetabolites.org/).

Results. The present strategy allowed us to correlate and predict the biological control capacity of the Bacillus species under study based on their taxonomic affiliation since at a shorter evolutionary distance from Bacillus subtilis a high potential capacity to produce biological control compounds was observed. However, the possibility that they acquire the ability to produce new biocontrol compounds during their evolutionary separation is not ruled out.

Conclusion. This work validates the correlation between the taxonomic affiliation of the studied Bacillus species and their biological control capacity, which is useful in the bioprospecting stage to design promising biopesticides.

Show Figures and/or Tables
Figure 1. Phylogenomic tree with the 123 studied type <em>Bacillus</em> species, where two main groups were identified: i) B. megaterium (pink color) and ii) B. subtilis (blue color)
Figure 1. Phylogenomic tree with the 123 studied type Bacillus species, where two main groups were identified: i) B. megaterium (pink color) and ii) B. subtilis (blue color)
Table 1. Type strain species belonging to the genus <em>Bacillus</em> downloaded from the EzBioCloud platform, which were used in this study
Table 1. Type strain species belonging to the genus Bacillus downloaded from the EzBioCloud platform, which were used in this study
  • Open access
  • Scientific Article

Aerial and terrestrial digital images for quantification of powdery mildew severity in Ayocote bean (Phaseolus coccineus)

byAlfonso Muñoz Alcalá, Gerardo Acevedo Sánchez, Diana Gutiérrez Esquivel, Oscar Bibiano Nava, Ivonne García González, Norma Ávila Alistac, María José Armenta Cárdenas, María del Carmen Zúñiga Romano, Juan José Coria Contreras, Serafín Cruz Contreras, Gustavo Mora Aguilera*

Received: 18/July/2023 – Published: 06/March/2024DOI: https://doi.org/10.18781/R.MEX.FIT.2312-1

Abstract Background/Objective. Epidemiological research on Phaseolus coccineus is lacking. The aim was to develop and validate digital methods to quantify the severity associated with powdery mildew in ayocote bean.

Materials and Methods. An ayocote bean plot with 65.3 % incidence and 22.7 % average powdery mildew foliar severity was selected. Based on 250 leaves collected in field with varying severity degrees, eight 7- and 8-class logarithmic-diagrammatic scales (ELD) were designed and validated in a controlled environment (CEV) and field (FV). In Rstudio®, accuracy (β), precision (R2), reproducibility (r), and agreement level were determined with Cohen’s kappa index (κw) and Lin’s concordance coefficient (LCC). Additionally, a Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA) was performed by scale and assessment environment for clustering by similarity evaluation. In ArcMap® v10.3, in a 15-quadrant block, an ‘image segmentation’ analysis was performed using supervised classification and maximum likelihood to estimate powdery mildew severity and an indicator of canopy coverage index (VCI).

Results. In VEC-1, v1r2 (ELD-7c; β=1.07, R2=0.93, r=0.87) and v1r1 (ELD-8c; β=0.97, R2=0.85, r=0.87) scales were best evaluated. In VEC-2, comparing clusters conformed in the HCA, the ELD-7c was the best scored with perfect accuracy (β>0.96), very high precision (R2>0.94), very high reproducibility (r=0.97-0.99) and very high agreement (κw>0.96; LCC>0.97); and in ELD-8c reproducibility and agreement decreased. In VCa, ELD-7c maintained optimal metrics, but ELD-8c reached ideal parameters for preventive ELD in early stages of powdery mildew (β>0.98, R2>0.98, r=0.99, κw=0.99-0.999, LCC=0.98-0.999). Image analysis estimated severity = 8.4 % (CI = 5.3 - 12.6 %) and ICV = 0.88 (CI = 0.76 - 0.99), contrasting with field assessment 47 % (CI = 38.8 - 55.3 %) and 0.46 (CI = 0.76 - 0.99), respectively, mainly with ICV > 0.94 due to less symptomatic leaf exposure. Suggests applicability for canopy estimation with restrictions for severity based on pathogen expression.

Conclusion. A methodology for ELD development is proposed, comprising: image acquisition, processing and quantification; controlled validation and field validation. Validation statistics included precision (R2); accuracy (β); reproducibility (Pearson’s coefficient and Hierarchical Cluster Analysis); and agreement (Lin’s Coefficient and Kappa Index), proposed in a comprehensive approach for first time. RGB-drone images are proposed to estimate a comprehensive vigor and severity coverage index.

Show Figures and/or Tables
Figure 1. Final versions of logarithmic-diagrammatic severity scales for powdery mildew in Ayocote bean (<em>Phaseolus coccineus</em>), selected for field validation. A) 7-class logarithmic-diagrammatic scales; B) 8-class logarithmic-diagrammatic scales.
Figure 1. Final versions of logarithmic-diagrammatic severity scales for powdery mildew in Ayocote bean (Phaseolus coccineus), selected for field validation. A) 7-class logarithmic-diagrammatic scales; B) 8-class logarithmic-diagrammatic scales.
Figure 2. A1 and B1. Logarithmic-diagrammatic scales of 7 and 8 classes for assessment of powdery mildew severity on Ayocote bean (<em>P. coccineus</em>) leaves, during the Controlled Environment Validation (CEV) process of 30 leaves by nine raters. A2 and B2. Heatmap of Pearson correlation coefficient (r) among nine raters by severity scale. Values of r = 0.8 – 1 indicate the reproducibility of each scale among raters. A3 and B3. Heatmap of severity class in 30 leaves evaluated by scale and rater. The color represents the class value assigned by the rater for each leaf. For rater and leaves, a Hierarchical cluster analysis is plotted, grouped by the complete method and Euclidean distance.
Figure 2. A1 and B1. Logarithmic-diagrammatic scales of 7 and 8 classes for assessment of powdery mildew severity on Ayocote bean (P. coccineus) leaves, during the Controlled Environment Validation (CEV) process of 30 leaves by nine raters. A2 and B2. Heatmap of Pearson correlation coefficient (r) among nine raters by severity scale. Values of r = 0.8 – 1 indicate the reproducibility of each scale among raters. A3 and B3. Heatmap of severity class in 30 leaves evaluated by scale and rater. The color represents the class value assigned by the rater for each leaf. For rater and leaves, a Hierarchical cluster analysis is plotted, grouped by the complete method and Euclidean distance.
Figure 3. Correlation graphs between severity (y) assessed using the scale and real values (x) by nine raters during the Controlled Environment Validation (CEV) with 30 <em>Phaseolus coccineus</em> leaves. The linear regression equation (y = βo + βx + e) is fitted to determine β, R2, and p-value parameters using the stat_poly_eq function. A. LDS-7 classes. B. LDS-8 classes.
Figure 3. Correlation graphs between severity (y) assessed using the scale and real values (x) by nine raters during the Controlled Environment Validation (CEV) with 30 Phaseolus coccineus leaves. The linear regression equation (y = βo + βx + e) is fitted to determine β, R2, and p-value parameters using the stat_poly_eq function. A. LDS-7 classes. B. LDS-8 classes.
Figure 4. A1 and B1. Logarithmic-diagrammatic scale of 7 and 8 classes for assessing powdery mildew severity on Ayocote bean (<em>P. coccineus</em>) leaves during the validation process of 30 leaves in the field by four selected raters. A2 and B2. Heatmap of Pearson correlation coefficient (r) among nine raters based on severity scale. Values of r = 0.8 – 1 indicate the reproducibility level of each scale among raters. A3 and B3. Heatmap of severity class on 30 leaves assessed by scale and rater. The color represents the class value assigned by the rater to each leaf. Hierarchical cluster analysis is performed by grouping raters and leaves using the ‘complete’ method and Euclidean distance
Figure 4. A1 and B1. Logarithmic-diagrammatic scale of 7 and 8 classes for assessing powdery mildew severity on Ayocote bean (P. coccineus) leaves during the validation process of 30 leaves in the field by four selected raters. A2 and B2. Heatmap of Pearson correlation coefficient (r) among nine raters based on severity scale. Values of r = 0.8 – 1 indicate the reproducibility level of each scale among raters. A3 and B3. Heatmap of severity class on 30 leaves assessed by scale and rater. The color represents the class value assigned by the rater to each leaf. Hierarchical cluster analysis is performed by grouping raters and leaves using the ‘complete’ method and Euclidean distance
Figure 5. Correlation plots between severity (y) assessed by scale and actual values (x) from four raters during Field Validation (VCa) with 30 <em>Phaseolus coccineus</em> leaves. The linear regression equation (y = βo + βx + e) is fitted to determine parameters β, R2, and p-value using the stat_poly_eq function. A. LDS-7classes. B. LDS-8classes.
Figure 5. Correlation plots between severity (y) assessed by scale and actual values (x) from four raters during Field Validation (VCa) with 30 Phaseolus coccineus leaves. The linear regression equation (y = βo + βx + e) is fitted to determine parameters β, R2, and p-value using the stat_poly_eq function. A. LDS-7classes. B. LDS-8classes.
Figure 6. Estimation of canopy and severity indicators using RGB imagery (13 mpx) from Phantom 3 processed through supervised segmentation algorithm in ArcMap® v10.3. A1. Image of the total experimental area (40 x 52 m). Captured at 50 m altitude. A2. Block of 15 selected quadrants based on uniformity in host continuity, canopy, and maximum inductivity. Continuous yellow lines depict quadrant divisions. Dashed white lines represent selected blocks for algorithm versus real image estimation. Captured at 27 m. A3. Image at 5 m of a selected sector for designing ‘RGB signature’ with crop categories (foliar tissue, flowering, powdery mildew, and soil coverage).
Figure 6. Estimation of canopy and severity indicators using RGB imagery (13 mpx) from Phantom 3 processed through supervised segmentation algorithm in ArcMap® v10.3. A1. Image of the total experimental area (40 x 52 m). Captured at 50 m altitude. A2. Block of 15 selected quadrants based on uniformity in host continuity, canopy, and maximum inductivity. Continuous yellow lines depict quadrant divisions. Dashed white lines represent selected blocks for algorithm versus real image estimation. Captured at 27 m. A3. Image at 5 m of a selected sector for designing ‘RGB signature’ with crop categories (foliar tissue, flowering, powdery mildew, and soil coverage).
Table 1. Average accuracy (β), precision (R2), and reproducibility (r) of eight logarithmic-diagrammatic severity scales for evaluating powdery mildew in <em>Phaseolus coccineus</em>.
Table 1. Average accuracy (β), precision (R2), and reproducibility (r) of eight logarithmic-diagrammatic severity scales for evaluating powdery mildew in Phaseolus coccineus.
Table 2. Parametric comparison of nine raters relative to the real value, to determine accuracy (βx), precision (R2), and agreement (LCC, κw) by severity class assessed during the validation process in a controlled environment (CEV) and in the field (FV)
Table 2. Parametric comparison of nine raters relative to the real value, to determine accuracy (βx), precision (R2), and agreement (LCC, κw) by severity class assessed during the validation process in a controlled environment (CEV) and in the field (FV)
Table 3. Comparison of canopy coverage index (VCI), plant canopy (PVI), and powdery mildew severity percentage estimated using RGB-drone image and field assessments.
Table 3. Comparison of canopy coverage index (VCI), plant canopy (PVI), and powdery mildew severity percentage estimated using RGB-drone image and field assessments.
  • Open access
  • Phytopathological note

Genetic variability of two Mexican Tomato brown rugose fruit virus isolates and expression of symptoms in tomato and pepper

byNorma Ávila Alistac, Gustavo Mora Aguilera, Héctor Lozoya Saldaña*, Erika J. Zamora Macorra, Camilo Hernández Juárez

Received: 18/July/2023 – Published: 06/March/2024DOI: https://doi.org/10.18781/R.MEX.FIT.2311-2

Abstract Background/Objective. The objective was to analyze the variability of two Mexican isolates of ToBRFV after a process of inoculation and multiplication in different commercial and Mexican landraces of tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) (15 materials) and pepper (Capsicum annuum) (20 materials), and to evaluate the expression of symptoms under greenhouse conditions.

Materials and Methods. In greenhouses, the post-infection variability of two isolates was analyzed: EM-JI2021 (State of Mexico) and C-JI2021 (Colima) in 15 genotypes of tomato and 20 of pepper. Each isolate was mechanically inoculated on five plants per genotype with a total of 150 plants (56 days old) of tomato and 200 of pepper. Three plants per genotype were used as controls. Sixty-one days after inoculation, one leaf per plant was collected for RT-PCR. Incidence and symptom expression were recorded. RNA extraction was by 2% CTAB. ToBRFV-F/ ToBRFV-R primers amplifying 475 bpb of the RpRd gene were used (SENASICA-CNRF). 24 RT-PCR products were sequenced, cleaned and aligned with NCBI Genbank records using MEGAv11.0.13. Based on epidemiological criteria, 34 sequences were selected from GenBank for variability analysis.

Results. Ten days after inoculation, tomato genotypes exhibited severe mosaic, mild mosaic, and reduced leaf area. In pepper, symptoms differentiated by genotype were observed, including hypersensitivity reaction, leaf deformation, stem necrosis, mosaic, yellowing, necrotic lesions, and asymptomatic condition. Between position 2,124 to 2,500 bp there was 99.74 % homology with the first report of ToBRFV in Jordan (KT383474.1). Homology >99.74 % was found with isolates from USA (MT002973.1) and Canada (OQ674195.1). C-JI2021 exhibited no variability, while EM-JI2021 generated three haplotypes: One nucleotide change (c.2,355T>C) was detected in Mulato (pepper) and Don R (tomato), while two substitutions (c.2,278A>T; c.2,355T>C) were detected in Santawest, Altius, Sahariana and Nebula (tomato).

Conclusion. The pathogenic intensity of ToBRFV varied from asymptomatic to severe depending on the combination of host, genotype, and haplotype. In short periods of infection, three haplotypes were detected, suggesting host-dependent mutagenic capacity of the virus.

Show Figures and/or Tables
Figure 1. Symptoms in commercial and native tomato material inoculated with Tomato brown rugose fruit virus. Symptoms of mild mosaic (IR143466, Nebula, Ametrino, Rio Grande, Citlali, Altius); severe mosaic, deformation and clearing of main leaf nervations (Volcano, Criollo-X and Angelle); healthy plant (Angelle control)
Figure 1. Symptoms in commercial and native tomato material inoculated with Tomato brown rugose fruit virus. Symptoms of mild mosaic (IR143466, Nebula, Ametrino, Rio Grande, Citlali, Altius); severe mosaic, deformation and clearing of main leaf nervations (Volcano, Criollo-X and Angelle); healthy plant (Angelle control)
Figure 2. Symptoms in chili (Capsicum annumm) inoculated with Tomato brown rugose fruit virus. A-C) Symptoms of apical deformation, necrosis in stem and nervations of Almuden leaves; D) Symptoms of apical deformation, slight necrosis in Cayenne nervations; E) Symptoms of apical deformation, mosaic, necrotic lesions in non inoculated Felicitas leaves
Figure 2. Symptoms in chili (Capsicum annumm) inoculated with Tomato brown rugose fruit virus. A-C) Symptoms of apical deformation, necrosis in stem and nervations of Almuden leaves; D) Symptoms of apical deformation, slight necrosis in Cayenne nervations; E) Symptoms of apical deformation, mosaic, necrotic lesions in non inoculated Felicitas leaves
Figure 3. Alignment of the partial sequence of the tomato brown rugose fruit virus replicase gene from 24 sequences of isolates obtained from 35 genotypes inoculates with isolates EM-JI2021 and C-JI2021, and from 34 sequences from different tomato and chili-producing countries. The alignment was performed using Geneious
Figure 3. Alignment of the partial sequence of the tomato brown rugose fruit virus replicase gene from 24 sequences of isolates obtained from 35 genotypes inoculates with isolates EM-JI2021 and C-JI2021, and from 34 sequences from different tomato and chili-producing countries. The alignment was performed using Geneious
Table 1. Complete Tomato brown rugose fruit virus sequences obtained from the GenBank (NCBI) used for the alignment and compares with ToBRFV sequences from the study
Table 1. Complete Tomato brown rugose fruit virus sequences obtained from the GenBank (NCBI) used for the alignment and compares with ToBRFV sequences from the study
Table 2. Symptoms pf Tomato brown rugose fruit virus in commercial and native tomato and pepper materials expressed under greenhouse conditions
Table 2. Symptoms pf Tomato brown rugose fruit virus in commercial and native tomato and pepper materials expressed under greenhouse conditions
Table 3. Percentage of coverage and identity of two ToBRFV isolations inoculated in a total of 35 tomato and pepper genotypes under greenhouse conditions
Table 3. Percentage of coverage and identity of two ToBRFV isolations inoculated in a total of 35 tomato and pepper genotypes under greenhouse conditions
  • Open access
  • Phytopathological note

Expression of the RPM1-RIN4-RPS2 complex in two citrus species with contrasting response to Huanglongbing

byEric Ángel Mendoza Pérez, Ricardo Santillán Mendoza, Humberto Estrella Maldonado, Cristian Matilde Hernández, Felipe Roberto Flores de la Rosa*, Jacel Adame García

Received: 18/July/2023 – Published: 06/March/2024DOI: https://doi.org/10.18781/R.MEX.FIT.2307-6

Abstract Objetive/Antecedents. Persian lime (Citrus latifolia) shows a very high level of tolerance to Huanglongbing (HLB). A recent study suggests that genes from the RPM1-RIN4-RPS2 complex could be partly responsible for HLB tolerance in Persian lime, unlike other highly susceptible species such as orange (C. sinensis). The objective of this study was to compare the expression of this gene complex between orange, highly susceptible to HLB, and Persian lime, a tolerant species.

Materials and Methods. Sequences of the three genes of the complex for orange and Persian lime were obtained from databases of previously published works, alignments and primer design for gene expression were performed using various bioinformatics tools. Subsequently, tissue samples from symptomatic HLB-infected orange and Persian lime were obtained and infection was confirmed. The expression of the RPM1-RIN4-RPS2 genes was compared using endpoint RT-PCR.

Results. The presence of all three genes of the complex was determined in both orange and Persian lime, and it was also determined that they are highly conserved between both species. Additionally, it was observed that there is no differential expression for the RPM1 gene in symptomatic HLB tissue; however, there is a difference in the expression of the RPS2 and RIN4 genes.

Conclusion. The results suggest that the contrasting response to HLB could be associated with the activity of the interaction of the RIN4 and RPS2 genes, thus, this could be of interest for citrus genetic improvement aiming at HLB control.

Show Figures and/or Tables
Figure 1. Alignment of CsRIN4 and ClRIN4 genes sequences.
Figure 1. Alignment of CsRIN4 and ClRIN4 genes sequences.
Figure 2. Symptoms of HLB present in Persian lime leaves (A), Valencia orange (B), Persian lemon (C) and Valencia orange (D) fruits
Figure 2. Symptoms of HLB present in Persian lime leaves (A), Valencia orange (B), Persian lemon (C) and Valencia orange (D) fruits
Figure 3. Expression of the RPM1-RIN4-RPS2 complex by RT-PCR in Valencia orange, a species highly susceptible to HLB, and Persian lime, a species with a high level of tolerance to HLB
Figure 3. Expression of the RPM1-RIN4-RPS2 complex by RT-PCR in Valencia orange, a species highly susceptible to HLB, and Persian lime, a species with a high level of tolerance to HLB
  • Open access
  • Phytopathological note

Detection and molecular characterization of a 16SrII group phytoplasma associated with ‘witches broom’ disease in cactus (Opuntia sp.)

byCandelario Ortega Acosta, Reyna Isabel Rojas Martínez*, Daniel L. Ochoa Martínez, Manuel Silva Valenzuela

Received: 02/October/2023 – Published: 06/March/2024DOI: https://doi.org/10.18781/R.MEX.FIT.2310-2

Abstract Background/Objective. Phytoplasmas are obligate plant pathogens that exhibit strong specificity with their hosts. Typical symptoms induced by these pathogens include stunted growth and general decline, among others, and they rarely lead to plant death. The aim of this research was to determine the phytoplasma associated with the ‘witch’s broom’ symptom in an ornamental cactus (Opuntia sp.).

Materials and Methods. Four samples of ornamental cacti exhibiting ‘witch’s broom’ symptoms were collected from four commercial nurseries in Texcoco, State of Mexico. DNA extraction was performed on the samples, followed by PCR using specific primers for phytoplasmas (P1/P7 and R16F2n/R16R2). Phytoplasma determination was carried out through PCR, in vitro RFLP, sequencing, and phylogenetic analysis.

Results. According to the various analyses conducted, it was determined that the phytoplasma associated with the ornamental cactus belongs to the subgroup 16SrII-C.

Conclusion. Based on the obtained results, it is established that a phytoplasma from the 16SrII-C subgroup is associated with the ‘witch’s broom’ symptom in the ornamental cactus (Opuntia sp.).

Show Figures and/or Tables
Figure 1. A) Amplifications of 16S rDNA of phytoplasmas obtained using primers R16F2n/R16R2. Lane M; Molecular marker 100 pb, lane +; DNA from Dimorphotheca sinuata infected with “Candidatus Phytoplasma asteris” (16SrI-B), lane -; Negative control, PCR without a template, lane 1-4; samples of cactus (<em>Opuntia</em> sp.) with “witches’ broom” syndrome, from nurseries located in Texcoco, State of Mexico; B-C) “Witches’ broom” symptoms in an ornamental cactus.
Figure 1. A) Amplifications of 16S rDNA of phytoplasmas obtained using primers R16F2n/R16R2. Lane M; Molecular marker 100 pb, lane +; DNA from Dimorphotheca sinuata infected with “Candidatus Phytoplasma asteris” (16SrI-B), lane -; Negative control, PCR without a template, lane 1-4; samples of cactus (Opuntia sp.) with “witches’ broom” syndrome, from nurseries located in Texcoco, State of Mexico; B-C) “Witches’ broom” symptoms in an ornamental cactus.
Figure 2. RFLP analysis of the 16S rDNA of phytoplasmas amplified using primers R16F2n/R16R2 and digested with five restriction enzymes: EcoRI, HaeIII, KpnI, MseI and RsaI M: molecular marker 100 pb (Promega, USA); A) Positive control ‘Candidatus Phytoplasma asteris’ (I-B); B) Symptomatic sample of cactus from this study (Accession number: 0N413680); C) Restriction patterns <em>in silico</em>, generated from the sequences of gene 16S rDNA of the Cactus witches’-broom phytoplasma 16SrII-C (Accession number: AJ293216.2) of the reconnaissance sites for 17 restriction enzymes.
Figure 2. RFLP analysis of the 16S rDNA of phytoplasmas amplified using primers R16F2n/R16R2 and digested with five restriction enzymes: EcoRI, HaeIII, KpnI, MseI and RsaI M: molecular marker 100 pb (Promega, USA); A) Positive control ‘Candidatus Phytoplasma asteris’ (I-B); B) Symptomatic sample of cactus from this study (Accession number: 0N413680); C) Restriction patterns in silico, generated from the sequences of gene 16S rDNA of the Cactus witches’-broom phytoplasma 16SrII-C (Accession number: AJ293216.2) of the reconnaissance sites for 17 restriction enzymes.
Table 1. Phylogenetic tree created using the neighbor-joining method, with sequences of the 16S rDNA deposited in the GeneBank, showing the relationship between the phytoplasmas for groups 16SrI and 16SrII with the phytoplasma that induced “witches’ broom” in cactus (<em>Opuntia</em> sp.) (Accession number: 0N413680.1). The bar indicates the number of substitutions per nucleotides
Table 1. Phylogenetic tree created using the neighbor-joining method, with sequences of the 16S rDNA deposited in the GeneBank, showing the relationship between the phytoplasmas for groups 16SrI and 16SrII with the phytoplasma that induced “witches’ broom” in cactus (Opuntia sp.) (Accession number: 0N413680.1). The bar indicates the number of substitutions per nucleotides
  • Open access
  • Scientific Article

Diversity and antibiotic resistance in bacteria associated with symptoms of bacterial infection in Costa Rican crops

byLorena Uribe Lorío*, Lidieth Uribe, César Rodríguez, Luis Felipe Aráuz

Received: 26/May/2023 – Published: 26/February/2024DOI: https://doi.org/10.18781/R.MEX.FIT.2305-5

Abstract Objetive/Background. The aim of this was to assess the diversity and antibiotic resistance of bacteria isolated from 19 crops with bacterial infection symptoms.

Materials and Methods. This collection was identified using 16S rRNA gene sequencing and the Biolog system. Susceptibility and minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) for streptomycin, tetracycline, and gentamicin were determined using disk diffusion and E-test methods, respectively.

Results. A total of 55 species belonging to 20 bacterial genera were identified, with Pseudomonas, Serratia, Pantoea, and Stenotrophomonas being the most abundant. Approximately 27% of the isolates were categorized as pathogenic through the hypersensitivity reaction test, including phytopathogenic species like Pseudomonas syringae, P. cichorii, Pantoea anthophila, P. stewartii, Stenotrophomonas maltophilia, Dickeya oryzae, Erwinia billingiae, Pectobacterium aroidearum, and Enterobacter cloacae subsp. dissolvens. Resistance to at least one antibiotic was detected in 60% of isolates from 17 crops, with tomatoes, heart of palm, and lettuce exhibited the highest proportion of resistant bacteria (>80%). Streptomycin resistance was most common (35%), followed by tetracycline (28%) and gentamicin (9%).

Conclusion. The findings indicate the presence of antibiotic resistance in saprophytic and pathogenic bacteria associated with 17 out of 19 assessed crops, posing risks to the environment, phytosanitary conditions, and public health

Show Figures and/or Tables
Figure 1. Symptoms of bacterial infection from which the bacterial collection were isolated. A. Leaf spot in Boston Lettuce, B. Soft rot in Iceberg Lettuce, C. Necrotic spot on Tomato. D. Soft rot in Celery. E. Soft rot in Pepper. F. Soft rot in Dracaena. G. Soft rot in Pumpkin. H. Angular necrosis in Cabbage. I. Fruit spot in Mango.
Figure 1. Symptoms of bacterial infection from which the bacterial collection were isolated. A. Leaf spot in Boston Lettuce, B. Soft rot in Iceberg Lettuce, C. Necrotic spot on Tomato. D. Soft rot in Celery. E. Soft rot in Pepper. F. Soft rot in Dracaena. G. Soft rot in Pumpkin. H. Angular necrosis in Cabbage. I. Fruit spot in Mango.
Figure 2. Cladograma construido con el método del vecino más cercano a partir de 70 secuencias parciales del gen ARNr 16S de bacterias aisladas de lesiones en plantas y secuencias de cepas de referencia. Se evaluó la topología del árbol realizando 1 000 remuestreos y se utilizó la secuencia de <em>Bacillus</em> subtilis como grupo externo. Los símbolos en el exterior del árbol indican los aislamientos clasificados como resistentes a Estreptomicina, Tetraciclina y Gentamicina y sus combinaciones (círculos) y aquellos con Reacción hipersensible positiva (triángulos)Cladogram constructed using the nearest neighbor method from 70 partial sequences of the 16S rRNA gene of bacteria isolated from plant lesions and sequences of reference strains. The tree topology was assessed through 1,000 resamplings, with the sequence of <em>Bacillus</em> subtilis used as an outgroup. Symbols on the outer part of the tree indicate isolates classified as resistant to Streptomycin, Tetracycline, and Gentamicin, as well as their combinations (circles), and those with a positive Hypersensitive Reaction (triangles).
Figure 2. Cladograma construido con el método del vecino más cercano a partir de 70 secuencias parciales del gen ARNr 16S de bacterias aisladas de lesiones en plantas y secuencias de cepas de referencia. Se evaluó la topología del árbol realizando 1 000 remuestreos y se utilizó la secuencia de Bacillus subtilis como grupo externo. Los símbolos en el exterior del árbol indican los aislamientos clasificados como resistentes a Estreptomicina, Tetraciclina y Gentamicina y sus combinaciones (círculos) y aquellos con Reacción hipersensible positiva (triángulos)Cladogram constructed using the nearest neighbor method from 70 partial sequences of the 16S rRNA gene of bacteria isolated from plant lesions and sequences of reference strains. The tree topology was assessed through 1,000 resamplings, with the sequence of Bacillus subtilis used as an outgroup. Symbols on the outer part of the tree indicate isolates classified as resistant to Streptomycin, Tetracycline, and Gentamicin, as well as their combinations (circles), and those with a positive Hypersensitive Reaction (triangles).
Figure 3. A. Halos indicating sensitivity to antibiotics on Oxoid discs for gentamicin and tetracycline, and resistance to streptomycin (absence of a halo) in the Kirby Bauer disk diffusion test. B. Bacteria with a minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of 0.25 μg mL-1 for gentamicin, determined by the E-test method. C. Bacteria with a MIC of 32 μg mL-1 for the same antibiotic.
Figure 3. A. Halos indicating sensitivity to antibiotics on Oxoid discs for gentamicin and tetracycline, and resistance to streptomycin (absence of a halo) in the Kirby Bauer disk diffusion test. B. Bacteria with a minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of 0.25 μg mL-1 for gentamicin, determined by the E-test method. C. Bacteria with a MIC of 32 μg mL-1 for the same antibiotic.
Figure 4. Proportion of bacteria resistant (MIC ≥ 12 μg mL-1) to the antibiotics Streptomycin (Str), Tetracycline (Tet), and Gentamicin (Gent), as well as their combinations, in the analyzed hosts that had more than one isolation
Figure 4. Proportion of bacteria resistant (MIC ≥ 12 μg mL-1) to the antibiotics Streptomycin (Str), Tetracycline (Tet), and Gentamicin (Gent), as well as their combinations, in the analyzed hosts that had more than one isolation
Table 3. Bacterial genera identified and the frequency of bacteria resistant to the antibiotics Streptomycin (Strept), Tetracycline (Tetra), and Gentamicin (Gent)
Table 3. Bacterial genera identified and the frequency of bacteria resistant to the antibiotics Streptomycin (Strept), Tetracycline (Tetra), and Gentamicin (Gent)
Table 1. Diversity and antibiotic resistance in bacteria associated with symptoms of bacterial infection in Costa Rican crops
Table 1. Diversity and antibiotic resistance in bacteria associated with symptoms of bacterial infection in Costa Rican crops
Table 2. Molecular identification and resistance levels to streptomycin, tetracycline, and gentamicin of bacteria associated with infection symptoms in crops collected from 2006-2009 in Costa Rica.
Table 2. Molecular identification and resistance levels to streptomycin, tetracycline, and gentamicin of bacteria associated with infection symptoms in crops collected from 2006-2009 in Costa Rica.
  • Open access
  • Scientific Article

Epidemiological etiology of Erysiphe sp. and putative viral and phytoplasma-like symptoms in Ayocote bean (Phaseolus coccineus)

byMaría José Armenta Rojas, Norma Ávila Alistac, María del Carmen Zúñiga Romano, Gerardo Acevedo Sánchez, Alfonso Muñoz Alcalá, Rene Gómez Mercado, Juan José Coria Contreras, Diana Gutiérrez Esquivel, Serafín Cruz Izquierdo, Ivonne García González, Oscar Bibiano Nava, Gustavo Mora Aguilera*

Received: 30/October/2023 – Published: 12/February/2024DOI: https://doi.org/10.18781/R.MEX.FIT.2310-7

Abstract Introduction/Objective. Ayocote bean (Phaseolus coccineus) has potential as a source of resistance in breeding programs because it exhibits greater tolerance to plant pathogens than P. vulgaris. However, its sanitary characterization is insipient; therefore, the purpose of this work was to carry out an etiological-epidemiological diagnosis, with emphasis on presumptive symptoms of viral and phytoplasmic organisms, and a typical fungal signs of powdery mildew.

Materials and Methods. A plot (50 x 62 m) of flowering Ayocote bean was selected. It was divided into 80 (8 x 10) quadrats (6 x 6 m) and 720 subquadrats (2 x 2 m). From 25 plants with powdery-mildew-type leaf symptoms, mycelium was collected with adhesive tape for light microscopy observation and taxonomic identification. Length-width measurements were made on 60 conidia. Pure mycelium collected in situ and ex situ from 1-5 leaflets/plant was used for genomic analysis by PCR with universal primers ITS1 and ITS4. Samples were sequenced in Macrogen Inc. Korea. A total of 63 plants and 121 trifoliate leaves with viral and phytoplasmic symptoms were collected by direct sampling. In 88/121 samples, genomic analysis was performed by PCR with universal primers for Potyvirus (1), Begomovirus (2), and Phytoplasmas (1). Sequence editing and analysis were performed in SeqAssem and BLASTn/GenBank. Phylogenetic constructions were developed in Mega 11 with MUSCLE, Maximum Likelihood (ML), and HKY substitution model (1000-Bootstrap). Putative powdery mildew severity (%), flower damage (%), Macrodactylus sp. adult density, and plant vigor (%) were evaluated in 80 quadrats (3subquadrats/quadrat) with App-Monitor®v1.1 configured with a 5-class scale. In GoldenSurfer® v10, Kriging geostatistical analysis was performed to determine the spatial interrelationship between these variables.

Results. Erysiphe vignae was identified as associated with powdery mildew of P. coccineus. The fungus, with hyaline, ovoid to ellipsoid conidia measuring 31.74 ± 0.3419 μm x 15.11 ± 0.1579 μm, without the presence of fibrosin bodies, had 100% genomic homology. This is the first report in Mexico. With average July-August temperature and relative humidity of 16.3 °C (±5.8) and 92.8 % (±10.7), respectively, powdery mildew leaf incidence and severity were 65.3 and 22.7 % (±16.9, range: 0 - 66.5 %), respectively. The most inductive focus (60- 80 % severity) had an aggregate e 4-quadrat pattern (96 m2, lag = 4 and σ2-s = 450). Inoculum dispersal was significantly associated with dominant North-South winds and plant vigor (lag = 4 and σ2-s = 470). Flower damage was inconclusive in its spatial association with powdery mildew and Macrodactylus sp. suggesting uncorrelated events. No Potyvirus, Begomovirus, or Phytoplasmas were detected associated with yellowing, leaf distortion, mosaic, internode shortening, and other symptoms observed in situ. This confirms the relative tolerance/resistance reported for P. coccineus.

Conclusion. E. vignae (Erysiphales: Erysiphaceae) associated with P. coccineus is reported for the first time in Mexico with moderate to intense epidemic level, which indicates its susceptible condition to this fungus. However, negative results for Potyvirus, Begomovirus, and Phytoplasmas, validate the apparent tolerance/ resistance of P. coccineus to these organisms.

Show Figures and/or Tables
Figura 2. Morphological and genomic identification of powdery mildew in Ayocote bean (<em>Phaseolus coccineus</em>). A. hyaline, ovoid to ellipsoid conidia; B-C. cylindrical and erect conidiophores; D-F. germinating conidia; G. Amplification of the internal transcribed spacer region (ITS) of nuclear ribosomal DNA (~500 bp) of five samples of cenicilla DNA (1-5), two positive PCR controls (+) belonging to the ITS region of <em>Alternaria</em> and <em>Fusarium</em> genera, 1 kb molecular weight marker (M) plus Invitrogen and negative PCR control (-); H. phylogenetic tree performed by Maximum Likelihood (ML) and the Hasegawa-Kishino-Yano substitution model with 1000 Bootstrap replications, based on ITS region of fungal sequences belonging to Erysiphe genus (Table 2). The study sequences are: FAC6, FAC7, FAC8 and FAC9 (red dot). Oidium sp. (accession number: EU377475) was included as outgroup
Figura 2. Morphological and genomic identification of powdery mildew in Ayocote bean (Phaseolus coccineus). A. hyaline, ovoid to ellipsoid conidia; B-C. cylindrical and erect conidiophores; D-F. germinating conidia; G. Amplification of the internal transcribed spacer region (ITS) of nuclear ribosomal DNA (~500 bp) of five samples of cenicilla DNA (1-5), two positive PCR controls (+) belonging to the ITS region of Alternaria and Fusarium genera, 1 kb molecular weight marker (M) plus Invitrogen and negative PCR control (-); H. phylogenetic tree performed by Maximum Likelihood (ML) and the Hasegawa-Kishino-Yano substitution model with 1000 Bootstrap replications, based on ITS region of fungal sequences belonging to Erysiphe genus (Table 2). The study sequences are: FAC6, FAC7, FAC8 and FAC9 (red dot). Oidium sp. (accession number: EU377475) was included as outgroup
Figura 3. Presumptive field symptoms of phytoplasma infection in Ayocote bean (<em>Phaseolus coccineus</em>). A. Putative symptoms to phytoplasmas. Including leaf deformation, brown or violet coloration, obvious purplish coloration on veins of back young leaves, stunting, slight yellowing of leaves; B. Examples of six trifoliate leaves showing presumptive symptoms of phytoplasmas, included in PCR diagnosis; C. Agarose gel electrophoresis of 24 samples processed by nested PCR. PCR-amplified positive controls only.
Figura 3. Presumptive field symptoms of phytoplasma infection in Ayocote bean (Phaseolus coccineus). A. Putative symptoms to phytoplasmas. Including leaf deformation, brown or violet coloration, obvious purplish coloration on veins of back young leaves, stunting, slight yellowing of leaves; B. Examples of six trifoliate leaves showing presumptive symptoms of phytoplasmas, included in PCR diagnosis; C. Agarose gel electrophoresis of 24 samples processed by nested PCR. PCR-amplified positive controls only.
Figura 4. Geostatistical Kriging contour maps and variograms of phytosanitary variables and vigor in Ayocote bean. A. Powdery mildew severity, B. Flower damage, C. Density of <em>Macrodactylus sp.</em> adults and D. Plant canopy. For adult analysis, cumulative of three subquadrants per quadrant was calculated. For the analysis of powdery mildew severity, flower damage, and plant canopy, the maximum damage obtained per quadrant was calculated. Omnidirectional variograms were obtained by the Spherical method. X-axis = distance-lag in quadrants and Y-axis = variance (σ2)
Figura 4. Geostatistical Kriging contour maps and variograms of phytosanitary variables and vigor in Ayocote bean. A. Powdery mildew severity, B. Flower damage, C. Density of Macrodactylus sp. adults and D. Plant canopy. For adult analysis, cumulative of three subquadrants per quadrant was calculated. For the analysis of powdery mildew severity, flower damage, and plant canopy, the maximum damage obtained per quadrant was calculated. Omnidirectional variograms were obtained by the Spherical method. X-axis = distance-lag in quadrants and Y-axis = variance (σ2)
Figure 1. Sampling methodology to identify and assess severity of fungal, presumtive viral/phytoplasmal symptoms, and entomological signs on <em>Phaseolus coccineus</em>. A. 13mpx image at 50m using DJI® Phantom-3 drone, showing quadrantization of experimental plot. Yellow-lines correspond to 6x6 m quadrants, and white-lines to 2x2 m subquadrants. Asterisks indicate randomly selected subquadrants/quadrants; B. Field quadrant marking with wooden-stakes and a slat-net; C. Selection of subquadrant by placing wooden frame 1x1 m for assessment guidance; D. Dotted mosaic symptoms (left) and vein clearing (right), putative to virosis. Plants marked with stakes for traceability samples; E. Generalized yellowing with growth reduction (left), mosaic with leaf deformation (right) presumptive viral; F. Leaf symptom with white fungal mycelial growth putative to powdery mildew; G. Front leaflet showing white mycelial growth. H. <em>Macrodactylus sp.</em> adults, and flowering color morphology of <em>P. coccineus</em>. Note some petals showing small white-spots (see arrows).
Figure 1. Sampling methodology to identify and assess severity of fungal, presumtive viral/phytoplasmal symptoms, and entomological signs on Phaseolus coccineus. A. 13mpx image at 50m using DJI® Phantom-3 drone, showing quadrantization of experimental plot. Yellow-lines correspond to 6x6 m quadrants, and white-lines to 2x2 m subquadrants. Asterisks indicate randomly selected subquadrants/quadrants; B. Field quadrant marking with wooden-stakes and a slat-net; C. Selection of subquadrant by placing wooden frame 1x1 m for assessment guidance; D. Dotted mosaic symptoms (left) and vein clearing (right), putative to virosis. Plants marked with stakes for traceability samples; E. Generalized yellowing with growth reduction (left), mosaic with leaf deformation (right) presumptive viral; F. Leaf symptom with white fungal mycelial growth putative to powdery mildew; G. Front leaflet showing white mycelial growth. H. Macrodactylus sp. adults, and flowering color morphology of P. coccineus. Note some petals showing small white-spots (see arrows).
Table 1. Primers, sequences, and amplicon size for genomic identification of Potyvirus, Begomovirus, Phytoplasmas and eukaryotic microorganisms in <em>P. coccineus</em> plants exhibiting signs of powdery mildew and putative virus and phytoplasma symptoms.
Table 1. Primers, sequences, and amplicon size for genomic identification of Potyvirus, Begomovirus, Phytoplasmas and eukaryotic microorganisms in P. coccineus plants exhibiting signs of powdery mildew and putative virus and phytoplasma symptoms.
Table 2. Sequences obtained from the NCBI Genebank used to construct the phylogenetic tree for comparison with amplicon sequences obtained from four samples of powdery mildew fungus present in <em>P. coccineus</em> plants.
Table 2. Sequences obtained from the NCBI Genebank used to construct the phylogenetic tree for comparison with amplicon sequences obtained from four samples of powdery mildew fungus present in P. coccineus plants.
  • Open access
  • Phytopathological note

Phytopathology and cultural behaviors: putative introduction of Chaya-strain of Cassava common mosaic virus to Costa Rica

byMauricio Montero Astúa*, Izayana Sandoval Carvajal, Lisela Moreira Carmona, William Villalobos Muller, Laura Garita Salazar, Sofía Carvajal Rojas

Received: 30/July/2023 – Published: 30/December/2023DOI: https://doi.org/10.18781/R.MEX.FIT.2023-3

Abstract Background/Objective. Leaves of the shrub chaya (Cnidoscolus aconitifolius), spinach tree or ‘chicasquil’ (in Costa Rica), are consumed in the Mesoamerican culinary tradition, having its origin in South Mexico and Guatemala. The objective of this work was to verify the viral nature of the observed in a chaya plant disease and to identify the species of the virus.

Materials and Methods. Plant virus detection and identification was achieved by TEM, RT-PCR using degenerated primers to potexviruses, and sequencing. Pathogenicity tests were done by mechanical inoculation using chaya symptomatic tissue, on Nicotiana benthamiana and chaya plants.

Results. We report CsCMV detection in a chaya plant in Costa Rica with mosaic symptoms. Pathogenicity and association of virus and symptoms were demonstrated by mechanical inoculation in Nicotiana benthamiana and chaya plants. We hypothesize this infection corresponds to a recent introduction and discussed how cultural traditions impact the distribution of plant viruses.

Conclusion. The findings confirm the presence of a CsCMV-related virus, previously unreported for Costa Rica, in Cnidoscolus aconitifolius. The results herein highlighted the need to study its distribution and diversity throughout Latin America

Show Figures and/or Tables
Figure 1. Chaya (<em>Cnidoscolus aconitifolius</em>) sample 20.222, tentative var. ‘Estrella’, with mosaic symptoms and positive for <em>Cassava common mosaic virus</em> (CsCMV) (A). Mechanical inoculation of sample 20.222 on Nicotiana benthamina (B) and chaya, tentatively var. ‘Chayamansa’ (C) showing mosaic symptoms. Stablished cuttings from sample 21.030 in LaFOV-CIBCM greenhouse (D). Leaf morphology of var. ‘Picuda’ (E).
Figure 1. Chaya (Cnidoscolus aconitifolius) sample 20.222, tentative var. ‘Estrella’, with mosaic symptoms and positive for Cassava common mosaic virus (CsCMV) (A). Mechanical inoculation of sample 20.222 on Nicotiana benthamina (B) and chaya, tentatively var. ‘Chayamansa’ (C) showing mosaic symptoms. Stablished cuttings from sample 21.030 in LaFOV-CIBCM greenhouse (D). Leaf morphology of var. ‘Picuda’ (E).
Figure 2. Transmission electron microscope observations of leaf tissue of chaya (<em>Cnidoscolus aconitifolius</em>)
Figure 2. Transmission electron microscope observations of leaf tissue of chaya (Cnidoscolus aconitifolius)
Figure 3. Transmission electron microscope observations of leaf tissue of chaya (<em>Cnidoscolus aconitifolius</em>)
Figure 3. Transmission electron microscope observations of leaf tissue of chaya (Cnidoscolus aconitifolius)
Table 1. Chaya (<em>Cnidoscolus aconitifolius</em>) samples evaluated for viral symptoms and sources of stem cuttings for transmission assays.
Table 1. Chaya (Cnidoscolus aconitifolius) samples evaluated for viral symptoms and sources of stem cuttings for transmission assays.
  • Open access
  • Phytopathological note

Comparison of molecular protocols to detect Tomato brown rugose fruit virus in solanaceae hosts

byErika J. Zamora Macorra, Katia Aviña Padilla*, Rosemarie W Hammond, Daniel L. Ochoa Martínez

Received: 23/August/2023 – Published: 23/December/2023DOI: https://doi.org/10.18781/R.MEX.FIT.2023-5

Abstract Background/Objective. The Tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV) has emerged as a significant threat to Solanaceae crops, including tomato and pepper. Its presence in Mexico since 2018 has raised concerns about its impact on agricultural production. Early and accurate detection of this pathogen is essential to prevent its spread and mitigate its effects. In Mexico, several molecular techniques are employed for its diagnosis, including endpoint RT-PCR, RT-qPCR, and multiplex RT-qPCR.

Materials and Methods. This research aimed to assess the efficiency of different RNA extraction methods in combination with specific PCR primers for detecting ToBRFV.

Results. Among the methods tested, the CTAB-Trizol RNA extraction protocol combined with nested PCR using primers reported by Dovas et al. (2004) was identified as the most sensitive molecular method for detecting the virus.

Conclusion. This finding highlights the importance of selecting the appropriate combination of extraction and amplification protocols to achieve optimal sensitivity and accuracy in ToBRFV detection.

Show Figures and/or Tables
Figure 1. A-C) Symptoms of mosaic, leaf deformation, and leaf narrowing were evident in tomato saladette plants gathered from greenhouse settings. These plants tested positive for Tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV); D-E) visual observations on inoculated Nicotiana leaves revealed the presence of localized chlorotic and necrotic lesions caused by ToBRFV infection. The virus-positive plants utilized for the study were sourced from Tecoman, Colima, Mexico.
Figure 1. A-C) Symptoms of mosaic, leaf deformation, and leaf narrowing were evident in tomato saladette plants gathered from greenhouse settings. These plants tested positive for Tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV); D-E) visual observations on inoculated Nicotiana leaves revealed the presence of localized chlorotic and necrotic lesions caused by ToBRFV infection. The virus-positive plants utilized for the study were sourced from Tecoman, Colima, Mexico.
Figure 2. The evaluation of total RNA extraction methods involved comparing their effectiveness and yield, as measured by absorbance readings on a Nanodrop 2000® spectrophotometer. Among the methods tested, including Trizol®, CTAB 2%, and CTAB 2%-Trizol®, the CTAB 2%-Trizol® protocol yielded the highest concentration of total RNA, while the RNA isolation Kit produced the lowest concentration. This data was recorded through absorbance measurements at wavelengths of 260/280 and 260/230. The Nanodrop 2000® was used to quantify the extracted RNA’s concentration and assess its quality by these absorbance ratios. The results indicated that the CTAB 2%-Trizol® protocol was particularly effective in extracting high-quality RNA from the plant samples, making it a suitable choice for subsequent molecular analyses.
Figure 2. The evaluation of total RNA extraction methods involved comparing their effectiveness and yield, as measured by absorbance readings on a Nanodrop 2000® spectrophotometer. Among the methods tested, including Trizol®, CTAB 2%, and CTAB 2%-Trizol®, the CTAB 2%-Trizol® protocol yielded the highest concentration of total RNA, while the RNA isolation Kit produced the lowest concentration. This data was recorded through absorbance measurements at wavelengths of 260/280 and 260/230. The Nanodrop 2000® was used to quantify the extracted RNA’s concentration and assess its quality by these absorbance ratios. The results indicated that the CTAB 2%-Trizol® protocol was particularly effective in extracting high-quality RNA from the plant samples, making it a suitable choice for subsequent molecular analyses.
Figure 3. Evaluation and sensitivity of PCR primers. 1.5% agarose gels electrophoretic analysis of RT-PCR and Nested RT-PCR products (Ling´s primers expected size 842 pb; Rodríguez-Mendoza´s primers expected size 475 bp and Dovas´s primers expected size 400 pb). (-): sterilized water instead RNA. 100 bp = 100bp DNA Ladder (Invitrogen®). 1Kb= 1000 bp DNA ladder (Promega®). 10-3 and 10-4 = 0.001 and 0.0001 ng μL-1.
Figure 3. Evaluation and sensitivity of PCR primers. 1.5% agarose gels electrophoretic analysis of RT-PCR and Nested RT-PCR products (Ling´s primers expected size 842 pb; Rodríguez-Mendoza´s primers expected size 475 bp and Dovas´s primers expected size 400 pb). (-): sterilized water instead RNA. 100 bp = 100bp DNA Ladder (Invitrogen®). 1Kb= 1000 bp DNA ladder (Promega®). 10-3 and 10-4 = 0.001 and 0.0001 ng μL-1.
Table 1. Primers tested in this study for ToBRFV detection in tomato, tomatillo, and eggplant
Table 1. Primers tested in this study for ToBRFV detection in tomato, tomatillo, and eggplant
Table 2. Comparison of Primer References, Plant Sources, and RNA Detection Limits in source of infected plant material
Table 2. Comparison of Primer References, Plant Sources, and RNA Detection Limits in source of infected plant material
  • Open access
  • Phytopathological note

Use of endophytic microorganisms for the management of Tomato brown rugose fruit virus in tomato crop (Solamun lycopersicum)

byCarlos D. Ramos Villanueva, Guadalupe Carrillo Benitez, Erika J. Zamora Macorra*, Eduardo Santiago Elena, Samuel Ramírez Alarcón, Jezrael Jimenez Vidals, Ricardo Ricardo López

Received: 31/July/2023 – Published: 19/December/2023DOI: https://doi.org/10.18781/R.MEX.FIT.2023-1

Abstract Background and objective: The Tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV) is one of the main pathogens affecting tomato crops in Mexico. Despite efforts to prevent its spread, it is nearly impossible due to its low transmission percentage through seeds and its high susceptibility to being transmitted through cultural practices. Therefore, alternative management strategies are being sought. This research aimed to determine the effect of endophytic microorganisms applied to the soil on tomato plants infected with ToBRFV.

Materials and Methods. A tomato plant was used as an experimental unit, with 13 repetitions per treatment. The treatments on tomato plants infected with ToBRFV were Beauveria peruviencis, Trichoderma longibrachiatum, Pseudomonas sp. and water as a sick witness; a treatment of healthy plants treated with water was also included as an absolute control. The response variables were plant height, fresh weight of the aerial part and root and severity (two evaluations). Measurements were analyzed using Tukey-Kramer HSD tests for each pair. Results and conclusion: Significant differences were found Beauveria peruviencis, Trichoderma longibrachiatum, Pseudomonas sp. and water as a sick witness. The treatment that most favored the development of infected plants (79% taller and 15% heavier than infected mock) and reduced its severity was B. peruviensis, followed by Pseudomonas sp. On the other hand, the treatment that resulted in the least plant development (31% smaller than infected mock) and even increased the severity of the infection was T. longibrachiatum.

Show Figures and/or Tables
Figure 1. A: Infected plants with Tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV), treated with various microorganisms, and the diseased mock control. B: Healthy mock plants. C: Comparison among ToBRFV-infected plants treated with different microorganisms. D: Representative symptoms induced by ToBRFV, illustrating leaf mosaic at 20 days after inoculation (dai) and shoot deformation at 35 dai.
Figure 1. A: Infected plants with Tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV), treated with various microorganisms, and the diseased mock control. B: Healthy mock plants. C: Comparison among ToBRFV-infected plants treated with different microorganisms. D: Representative symptoms induced by ToBRFV, illustrating leaf mosaic at 20 days after inoculation (dai) and shoot deformation at 35 dai.
Figure 2. Mean of the response variables, obtained at the end of the experiment, for each treatment applied to ToBRFV- infected (diseased) and healthy tomato plants.
Figure 2. Mean of the response variables, obtained at the end of the experiment, for each treatment applied to ToBRFV- infected (diseased) and healthy tomato plants.
Figure 1. Comparison of mean values for response variables (height, severity, and weight of tomato plants) assessed under each treatment, accompanied by Tukey-Kramer HSD test-generated grouping letters.
Figure 1. Comparison of mean values for response variables (height, severity, and weight of tomato plants) assessed under each treatment, accompanied by Tukey-Kramer HSD test-generated grouping letters.

Page 5 of 8